One of my daughters read
Ethan Frome in high school because it was a class assignment. She hated the book.
Ethan Frome was written by Edith Wharton and published way back in 1911. Wharton was the first woman to win a Pulitzer Prize in 1920 for a later novel,
The Age of Innocence. I have not read
The Age of Innocence, but I read
Ethan Frome--because my daughter hated it.
It is a depressing story. However, it is well written--and short, which is probably one of the reasons it was assigned to the students in high school. Nevertheless, I am glad I was not forced to read it at a young age. Well-written novels are often foisted upon tender minds before they are ready to understand them. Worse, the books are then picked apart--piece by piece--until the students are completely sick of them.
I was forced to read
The Scarlet Letter, The Call of the Wild, and
The Old Man and the Sea when I was in high school. I appreciated
The Scarlet Letter most. I later read--on my own--
The House of the Seven Gables, which was also written by Nathaniel Hawthorne. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
I could not appreciate
The Call of the Wild. I am sure that a dog has a point of view, but I am also sure it is not quite that literate. Nevertheless, I read
The Sea Wolf recently, which was also written by Jack London. I liked it. It has
romance. It is also about people--not dogs.
The Old Man and the Sea was one of those books my high school teacher made into a torturous experience. Every bit of symbolism was pointed out. Yes, it is well-written--but tragic. Why do teachers insist on tragic, unhappy stories?
Maybe part of the reason some young people do not read today is due to the fact that they've been forced to read depressing books about sad, miserable people.
Why can't English teachers in high school assign happy, upbeat
romances? Not all
romances are jam-packed with sex. The main ingredient for a
romance is a happy ending.
Romances are uplifting and not depressing.
Please stop picking the books apart piece by piece. Let the young people enjoy them. Maybe they'll pick up another
romance and get hooked on reading for life.